Orsis and Tman I for one recognise that in mail centres as a result of down stream access we have lost a condisidable amount of up stream contracts. However all of the down stream access items connect with the final Royal Mail delivery.
Royal Mail delvier to all 28.5 million uk adressses and whilst in every recession we lose work and I have seen more recessions during my time in Royal Mail then i care to remember. When ever we go in to a reccession companies immediately cut back on mail postings. When compainies start moving forward and out of a reccision they decide to increase the amount they advirtise and post.
The problem i have is when Royal Mail removed WLA by weight in delivery offices and replaced it with MIST ( traffic recording in mail centres ) they said that delivery offices were over stating traffic by up to 17% and traffic and revenue did not match. The agreement talked about parrell recording to viafy traffic figures in delivery offices and in mail centres this did not happen. In fact when you refer back to previous traffic data, the loss of traffic claimed is often the traffic which Royal Mail said we were over recording and was never there in the first place. So the arguement could be that we are still delivering the same amount of traffic as we used to its just being recorded more accuately.
The other issue is that IPKs have not been changed to take into account the new type of mail which fulfilment traffic brings. In any case Royal Mail changed their pricing regime when they bought pricing by weight to take in to account the increase in flat and packet traffic which in delivery offices often result in more knocks on doors etc and time spent on delivery.
Post comm take Royal Mail`s figures as do the Government so it not the case that we are saying they are all in cahoots. The Government bill also recognises that Post comm have compained to both Royal Mail and the Government that Royal Mail have been less than helpful in allowing for Post Comm to examine both traffic and revnue. This is why Ofcom will be given more access.